You had a great discovery call. The vibe was good, the client seemed excited, you sent your proposal… and then you heard nothing. You follow up once. Twice. And still nothing. So what's going wrong, and more importantly, what do you do about it?
That's one of the four questions I answered live in a recent Q&A session, so whether you're trying to get proposals to convert, figuring out how to structure your packages, bringing in contractors, or selling to local business owners who want you to do everything… this one’s for you.
Why Your Proposals Are Stalling (And It's Not Your Pricing)
Sonya, a web designer who'd been in business for a couple of years and recently went full-time, shared that she was getting discovery calls but things kept stalling out after she sent proposals. She'd had a great call, sent the proposal, and then… crickets. She was considering closing on the call to speed things up and wasn't sure if that was the right move.
Here's what I told her, and what I'd tell anyone in this situation.
Closing on the call is a skill that can be learned, but it's never felt aligned with how I run my business or how I want to interact with clients. Feeling pressure to say yes on the spot can actually create resistance, and that doesn't feel good for anyone. So we don't teach it that way inside the Web Designer Academy.
What we do recommend instead is incentivizing the decision.
That means putting a deadline on your proposal, and not a punitive one, but a real one. You are not going to hold space on your development calendar for someone indefinitely. Your time is not an open-ended resource that's available whenever someone gets around to deciding.
So here's what a follow-up sequence should look like:
First, set a deadline. I typically give people a week to 10 days. That might feel long if you've heard sales experts say ‘if they're not an immediate yes, they're a no,' but at higher price points, that's not always true. Clients sometimes need a little time to coordinate schedules, check budgets, or finish a conversation with their business partner.
Second, build in follow-up with a reason. Don't just follow up to see ‘where they're at.' Every follow-up email should end with a direct yes or no question, like ‘Are you planning to move forward with this?' An email that ends in a period is easy to ignore. An email that ends in a question requests a response.
Third, incentivize the decision. For the Web Designer Academy and my coaching programs, I incentivize a single payment. You could offer a small discount on the deposit, or a bonus of some kind, if they decide by a certain date. This gives you a genuine reason to follow up and creates a real reason for them to act.
And when you're doing that final follow-up before you close the proposal out? Be direct about it. Something like, ‘I'm following up one last time before I close out your proposal and archive our conversation, are you planning on moving forward?' That message communicates that you're not sitting around waiting, that there's a real deadline, and that you'd genuinely like to work with them but the door isn't open forever.
But you have to get comfortable with not leaving the door open forever… and that’s where most web designers get stuck.
How to Apply the Package Matrix™ Method to VIP Days and Sprints
The second question came from Jess, an ecommerce specialist who works on Shopify builds and had moved from a VIP day model to what she calls sprints. She'd heard about the Package Matrix™ Method and was wondering how to apply it when the scope of each project varies and there's no fixed set of deliverables.
Jess shared that the friction points in her sprint model were revision time (clients wanting more than the 1 hour she included), support period length (clients wanting extensions on the 15-day post-project QA window), and scope creep, which she was handling by keeping a wish list of future project ideas.
Here's the key insight about Package Matrix™ that I shared with her. When you explicitly show someone all the levels of access, support, and service they could have chosen, and they chose the lower tier, holding your boundaries becomes so much easier. Because they already saw the higher option. They knew what it came with. They chose not to buy it.
So instead of framing the tiers by deliverables (which doesn't work if the deliverable is always a sprint), here are a few things to think through when building out your own Package Matrix™ for a sprint-based offer:
- What would the private-jet level of service look like for this offer? What would you need to earn to want to say yes to that?
- What level of support are you actually comfortable delivering at each tier? Build the tiers around what works for you, not just what sounds good on paper.
- If you'd never want someone to buy the highest tier (because you wouldn't actually want to do the work), don't include it. Package Matrix™ only works if the options are real.
- Two different deliverable sets (website vs. website plus email) aren't a Package Matrix™, they're two separate offers. Package Matrix™ is choosing from levels of the same thing.
The magic of Package Matrix™ on the delivery side is that it pre-sets the boundaries. If a client later asks for extras you didn't include, you can genuinely say, ‘That's included in the premium tier, would you like to upgrade?'
This is one of the things we go deep on inside The Package Matrix™ Method course.
How to Handle Outsourcing and Subcontracting (Without Overthinking It)
Alyssa asked how to outline the scope of work when you plan to bring in another designer or specialist, like an SEO copywriter, and how to ‘convince' your client that it's okay for someone else to do part of the work.
Here's my honest take on this. You don't need to convince your client. You're running a business. You get to hire contractors. The sky is blue.
Most seasoned business owners will hear ‘I'm working with an SEO copywriter on this part, I'll be managing the whole process and you'll get to review everything just as you would if I were doing it myself' and their reaction will be ‘cool, great, she's working with a specialist.'
Now, is it possible a client could push back? Sure. If that happens, here's how I'd approach it.
- Start with empathy. “I can totally see why you might have expected that.” Don't get defensive.
- Get curious. “Help me understand your concerns about this.” Let them talk.
- Explain the reality. “While they're working on that, I'm focused on this other part. My job is to make sure everything meets our standards.”
- If they still resist, offer a choice. “We can either keep the contractor and stick to the current timeline, or I can handle all of it and we'll adjust the timeline. Your call.”
Most of the time, the problem you're worried about isn't actually going to happen. We tend to build these scenarios up in our heads before they occur. My advice is to let the problem come to you, and then deal with it if it does. More often than not, you'll say it with confidence and the client will just say… okay, cool.
How to Sell a Website When Local Clients Want You to Do It All
Kristin is working to serve more local business clients, specifically contractors and realtors, and she was running into a challenge. When she got on calls with these clients, they wanted everything. Social media, ads, email, the website… and they seemed disappointed when she said her focus was just on the website.
The reframe I offered her is this. Your website is a completely different thing than marketing. And most local business owners don't understand that yet.
The way I'd approach those conversations is something like this: “What I do is make sure that all of the marketing you're already doing, or planning to do, actually works. Social media, paid ads, Google business profile, email… all of that is sending people somewhere. I'm the person who makes sure that when they get there, the site does its job. It captures their attention. It moves them forward. It turns traffic into clients.”
That framing does a few things. It doesn't make Kristin sound like she's offering less. It makes her sound like she's the foundation that everything else depends on – which is true.
On the numbers conversation, which Kristin was nervous about, I'd encourage you to come at it from a value angle, not a cost comparison. Don't try to show them that a $10,000 website is a good deal versus $1,000 a month in social media ads. That just focuses them on cost.
Instead, ask them the questions that get them thinking about what this is actually worth to them. What is one new client worth to you? What's your average project or transaction size? How many new clients a month would change things for you? Then paint the picture. If I help your site convert one more client a month, what would that mean over a year?
Then the leaky bucket analogy does the rest of the work: Spending money on marketing before you have a solid website is like pouring water into a leaky bucket. You can keep pouring more and more in, but it's never going to fill up. What I do is fix the bucket. And then when you go spend your marketing dollars, you're actually going to keep more of the traffic that's coming in.
You're building revenue-generating assets for your clients. Every web designer who does this work is. And saying that out loud, with that kind of confidence and clarity, is how you shift the conversation from “how much is this going to cost me” to “how much is this going to make me.”
Resources Mentioned
Web Designer Academy – webdesigneracademy.com
Next Level Mastermind – webdesigneracademy.com/next-level-mastermind
Package Matrix™ Method – https://shannonmattern.com/matrix
Related Episodes
Episode 198: How to Make More with Less Web Design Clients – webdesigneracademy.com/198
Episode 194: The Daily Habit for Building a Full Web Design Client Pipeline with Julia Taylor – webdesigneracademy.com/194
Episode 193: Stop Waiting for Referrals and Get Booked Out with Sarah Noel Block – webdesigneracademy.com/193
About Shannon Mattern
Shannon Mattern is a pricing strategist, creator of the Package Matrix™ and the founder of the Web Designer Academy, where she helps experienced women web designers package, price, and sell their services so they can build profitable, sustainable businesses without burnout.
Website: webdesigneracademy.com
For Service Providers: https://shannonmattern.com
YouTube: @profitablewebdesigner
LinkedIn: shannonmattern
What should I say when a client doesn't respond to my web design proposal?
Follow up directly and with a yes or no question. Something like 'I'm following up one last time before I close out your proposal - are you planning to move forward?' is clear, respectful, and way more likely to get a response than a vague 'just checking in' email. End every follow-up with a question mark.
How do I create a Package Matrix™ for VIP days or sprints?
Instead of building tiers around deliverables (since the deliverable is always the sprint), build them around the conditions of working with you - revision hours, support period length, access, and response time. The goal is to show clients all the levels of service they could have, so that whatever tier they choose becomes the pre-agreed boundary.
Do I need to tell my web design clients when I subcontract work?
You're running a business and you're allowed to hire contractors. You don't need your client's permission, but it's professional and transparent to let them know. Most clients, especially experienced business owners, will see it as a sign that you're organized and strategic. If you get any pushback, start with empathy, ask questions, and offer them a choice.
How do I sell a website to local business clients who want social media and marketing too?
Reframe your role. You're not the person who does all the marketing - you're the person who makes sure all the marketing they do actually works. Their website is a revenue-generating asset, the foundation that everything else depends on. Use the leaky bucket analogy: there's no point spending money on marketing if the site isn't built to convert the traffic that shows up.