If you have ever gotten to the end of a web design project and thought, “I should have charged double” – this episode is for you.
Episode 198 of the Profitable Web Designer podcast is the replay of our April live Q&A session on breaking through your pricing ceiling. I walked through the three-step framework we teach inside the Web Designer Academy – free consultation, paid discovery, and Package Matrix™ – and then answered real questions from web designers just like you on everything from how to present add-on services, to whether paid discovery is worth it for a small brochure site, to what to do when your design skills feel like they are holding you back.
Let's get into it.
It Is Not a Pricing Problem. It Is a Process Problem.
The most common thing I hear from web designers who are undercharging is some version of: I just need to figure out how to charge more. And I understand that instinct. But here is what I have seen after working with hundreds of web designers inside the Web Designer Academy: the price is not actually the problem. The process is.
Most web designers run their consultations by asking questions to scope the project – what do you need, is this a new build or a redesign, what functionality do you want – and then they go away and agonize over the proposal. They second-guess the price. They wonder if the client will say it is too much. And then one of two things happens: the client ghosts, or the client says yes and the designer gets to the end of the project thinking, I should have charged double.
Sound familiar?
Here is what has to be true before any client buys anything. They need to believe that saying yes will leave them with more – more time, more money, more freedom, not less. They need to trust that you are the one who can actually get them there. And they need to feel like they are in control of the decision. When your consultation process is focused on scoping deliverables and matching them to a package, you are not building any of those three things. You are just presenting a cost.
That is what our process fixes.
The Three-Step Framework: Free Consultation, Paid Discovery, Package Matrix
Inside the Web Designer Academy, we teach a specific sequence that shifts your client conversations from cost-based to value-based. Here is the quick version.
Free Consultation
Instead of asking all of the questions you need to scope the project, you ask questions that establish the value of the project and the cost of not moving forward. Simple questions like: what is one new client worth to your business? What happens if this website is not working six months from now? That information is what makes your proposal feel like an obvious yes later – not your list of deliverables.
The free consultation is where you establish whether you are a good fit, learn about their business, and – most importantly – get the client to talk themselves into the value of moving forward. You are not selling anything yet. You are being curious and asking great questions.
Paid Discovery
At the end of the free consultation, you offer two options: paid discovery first (where they pay you to develop the strategy), or skip straight to the Package Matrix™. Either way is fine – you let them decide. But the key is that you are in control of what their choices are.
Paid discovery is not asking people to pay you just to get on a call. It is getting paid for the strategy work you are probably already doing for free – either before the project to scope it, or after you book it when you realize the project is bigger than you thought. When clients go through your paid discovery process, they walk away with a website strategy and a clear picture of where they are now, where they need to go, and how you are going to get them there. That is what builds the trust that makes them willing to pay more.
We have had students present a Package Matrix™ after paid discovery and have clients book at higher than the budget they originally said they had. Because the process changed what the decision felt like.
Package Matrix™
The Package Matrix™ is how you make the offer to implement the strategy. Instead of presenting one price and hoping they say yes, you present options at different investment levels and let clients self-select. Some people are investment-minded – they want everything handled and they understand that paying now creates more later. Some are hustle-minded – they will roll up their sleeves if they have a guide. Some are expense-minded and want to start lean.
You do not know who you are talking to until you talk to them. So instead of guessing, you present options, tie each one back to what they told you they wanted, and let them tell you which feels like the right fit. You stop over-explaining and package stuffing. You design the decision the same way you would design a homepage to convert.
The result? Students going from $2,500 projects to $8,000, from $5,000 to $15,000, from $10,000 to $35,000 – with the same services and the same pool of clients that was already around them.
You can get our Package Matrix template at webdesigneracademy.com/template to see how it works.
Live Q&A: Real Questions from Real Web Designers
Q: How do I present add-on services without confusing the client?
Emily asked about how to handle add-on offers – things like social graphics, strategy calls, lead magnet creation. Should she list them on her website? Save them for the discovery call? Offer them as a hidden backend page?
My perspective on this is a little different from what you might have heard. When you list a bunch of deliverables and add-ons with prices on your website, you are designing a cost-based decision. You are basically asking the client: is this five-page website worth this much to you? And they are going to compare your price to every other web designer they can find.
What I recommend instead is to mention that you offer those services, but only bring them up in the context of the strategy conversation. If social graphics or email design are relevant to what the client needs to reach their goals, you include that in the strategy and in the Package Matrix™. You are not selling a menu. You are solving a problem, and your offer is tailored to that specific client's situation.
Q: Does paid discovery make sense for a small brochure site?
Lisa came to one of our live strategy calls and then asked here: should she use paid discovery for a small four-to-five page site, or is it only worth it for bigger projects?
Yes, absolutely use paid discovery for small projects. Here is what you miss when you do not: you miss the opportunity to paint the picture of why you are the perfect person for this project, to show how you work, to pre-frame the value, and to lead the client through the process from the very start. We have had students go through paid discovery on smaller projects and have the client book at a higher price than the budget they originally mentioned – because the process changed what the decision felt like.
Package Matrix™ works without paid discovery – we taught it that way for five years before adding the paid discovery step. But paid discovery accelerates everything. Even for a simple brochure site.
Q: My design aesthetic is not there yet. Do I need to wait to charge more?
Amber shared something I hear all the time: she does not feel like she has landed on a recognizable design aesthetic yet, and she is linking that to not feeling ready to charge more.
Here is what I told her: your price is not about you. People are not buying your vibe or your aesthetic. They are buying the outcomes and results they can create as a result of working with you. Can you capture the vibe of someone else's business? Can you meet with a client, understand their audience and goals and brand voice, and translate that into a website strategy and design that solves their business problems? If yes, you do not need to wait.
One of my most recent client success stories, Fabiana, does not even have a full website – she has a landing page because she has never gotten around to building it. She just sold a $20,000 project. It is not about the aesthetic. It is about changing your process so that you can charge more.
Q: How do I get my first Shopify client without using Upwork or Fiverr?
Pradeep asked how to land a first Shopify client through something other than the usual freelance marketplaces.
The very first thing I would do is tell the people already around you what you are working on. That sounds simple, but it is where most people start. Beyond that, I would find the people who mentor or teach your ideal clients. If you build Shopify sites, who are the podcasters, YouTubers, or coaches teaching product-based business owners how to sell on Shopify? Reach out to those people. Not to ask for a job – but to introduce yourself and offer to be a resource for their audience.
Be willing to be ghosted or ignored. But if you reach out with sincerity, take time to understand what they do and how they help their clients, and position yourself as someone who can solve a specific problem for those clients, you are building the kind of relationship-based pipeline that actually works. That is the marketing strategy we teach inside the Web Designer Academy: stop waiting for people to find you. Go make the first move.
Q: What about nonprofit clients – does the Package Matrix™ work for them?
Marcy runs a small agency working primarily with nonprofit organizations on very custom, complex builds. She was wondering whether the Package Matrix™ even applies to that kind of work.
It absolutely does. And I want to gently push back on something: nonprofit does not mean does not have money. Nonprofit means does not take a profit. It means that their website is part of their mission and vision, and so they invest in it. There is actually a strong argument that nonprofit clients understand investment-minded thinking especially well.
The Package Matrix™ is not just for initial web design projects – we also teach students how to package their ongoing support. Marcy already has clients who work with her long-term and come back over and over. That is an incredible opportunity to package that ongoing relationship and get paid well for the value you are already delivering, instead of having those conversations happen awkwardly after the fact.
You Can Implement This on Your Very Next Consultation
One of the things I emphasize the most is that you do not have to wait. You do not have to overhaul your website, change your services, or build a whole new system before you can start charging more. You change the words you use on your next consultation. You change how you frame the offer. You change what decision you are asking the client to make.
We have had students enroll in the Web Designer Academy on a Monday and fly by the seat of their pants to implement the strategy on a consultation scheduled that same week – and triple their price. One private coaching client was charging $10,000 when she joined. Within the first 60 days, she had booked her first paid discovery client who said no to all three options, a second paid discovery client who said yes to $35,000, and a third who said yes to $42,000.
Every project you undercharge on is time and money you never get back. You can change that on your very next consultation.
Resources Mentioned
- Package Matrix Template – webdesigneracademy.com/template
- Web Designer Academy – webdesigneracademy.com/program
- Book a Discovery Call with Shannon – webdesigneracademy.com/calendar
- Attend a Live Strategy Call – webdesigneracademy.com/open-house
- Simply Profitable Designer Summit – simplyprofitabledesigner.com
Related Episodes
- Episode 189: How To Price Custom Web Design Projects with Shannon Mattern
- Episode 191: How To Choose the Right Web Design Business Model
- Episode 186: The Web Designer's Guide to Dealing With Difficult Clients
About Shannon Mattern
Shannon Mattern is a pricing strategist, creator of the Package Matrix™ and the founder of the Web Designer Academy, where she helps experienced women web designers book higher-paying web design projects, charge more with confidence, run projects without overworking and burnout, and break through to their next level of income and freedom.
🎧 Profitable Web Designer Podcast: https://webdesigneracademy.com/podcast
🌐 Website: https://webdesigneracademy.com
📱Instagram: https://instagram.com/profitablewebdesigner
📱TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@profitablewebdesigner
📺 YouTube: https://youtube.com/@profitablewebdesigner
🤝 LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/in/shannonmattern
What is paid discovery in web design?
Paid discovery is a step in the web design sales process where the client pays you to develop a website strategy before any design or development work begins. Instead of doing that scoping and strategy work for free - either upfront in a proposal or after you book the project - you get paid for it. The client walks away with a clear strategy for their website, and you walk away with valuable information that allows you to price the implementation accurately and present a Package Matrix™ with options.
What is a Package Matrix™ for web designers?
A Package Matrix™ is a way of presenting your services as a set of options at different investment levels, rather than a single price or a menu of deliverables. Instead of asking a client to decide whether your deliverables are worth your price, you present two or three options that are tied to their specific goals - and you let them self-select based on how they think about investment and what level of involvement they want. The result is a value-based decision, not a cost-based one.
How do I stop undercharging as a web designer?
Undercharging is usually a process problem, not a pricing problem. The shift is to stop asking clients to evaluate whether your deliverables are worth your price, and start designing a sales conversation that gets them to see the value of the outcomes they will create by working with you. That means asking different questions in your consultation, offering paid discovery to establish your expertise and scope the project, and presenting a Package Matrix™ that puts the client in control of the decision while you stay in control of what the options are.
Do I need better design skills to charge more?
No. Your design skills are not what determine how much you can charge. What determines your price is how you position the value of working with you and how you structure the sales conversation. If you can meet with a client, understand their business goals, and build something that solves their real problems - you are already qualified to charge more. The shift is in your process, not your portfolio.
Does paid discovery work for small web design projects?
Yes. Even for a simple four-to-five page brochure site, paid discovery gives you the opportunity to show that you understand the client's business, demonstrate that you are the right person to lead the project, and pre-frame the value of working with you before the client ever sees a price. We have had students book projects at higher than the client's stated budget after going through paid discovery - because the process changes what the decision feels like.