If you've been building your web design proposals around deliverables… and wondering why clients keep pushing back on price, or asking “can you do it for less?”… I want you to know that's not a you problem. It's a pricing strategy problem. And it has a solution.
I'm Shannon Mattern, pricing strategist and founder of the Web Designer Academy, and I've been teaching this solution since 2018. I call it the Package Matrix™ (or Patrick, as we call him inside the Web Designer Academy, but more on that in a second).
Inside the Web Designer Academy, we focus on helping experienced women web designers stop undercharging and over-delivering and build simpler, more profitable businesses. Pricing is at the heart of almost everything we teach, because nothing else in your business works well if your pricing isn't working for you.
This post walks you through the full Package Matrix™ Method, the four rules that make it work, and the behavioral economics and pricing psychology behind why it converts so much better than traditional proposals.
The Real Reasons Web Designers Undercharge
Before we get to the solution, let's name the problem. When I started my freelance web design business back in 2014, I had all kinds of thoughts about what I could and couldn't charge. Sound familiar?
- “The people I know can't afford to pay more.”
- “I don't want to nickel and dime anyone.”
- “I underestimated the project. It's my fault.”
- “What if I mess something up? I've never done this for a paying client before.”
And even when I got past the pricing fears, I had delivery problems. I felt like I had to be on call 24/7. If a client asked for more, I felt bad saying no. If a project stalled, I'd take responsibility for it even when it wasn't mine to carry. I was providing first-class levels of service at bargain basement prices.
The thing is, these aren't character flaws. They're symptoms of a Pricing Paradigm™ that isn't working for you. And a paradigm is just a way of looking at the world. It's optional. It can change.
The Three Pricing Paradigms™ (and Why They Matter)
One of the foundational pieces of the Package Matrix™ Method is understanding Pricing Paradigms™ , both yours and your clients'. There are three:
1. Expense/Employee Mindset
This is the belief that money is finite, time is the currency, and someone else controls how much you can make. If you grew up in a household where “we can't afford it” was the default answer to most things, this might be deeply ingrained. In business, it shows up as undercharging, over-delivering, and assuming your clients can't afford to pay more because you'd never pay that much.
2. Hustle Mindset
Here, more skills and more hard work equal more money. It's better than expense mindset, but it leads to a ceiling. You're still trading time for money. You keep adding things to your packages to feel like they justify the price.
3. Investment Mindset
Money isn't tied to time at all. People exchange money for things they value more than money. Your job is to help clients see the future value of what you create for them, not to defend your hours.
Here's what's important to understand: your clients have their own Pricing Paradigm™, and it's constantly in flux. You have no idea whether the person sitting across from you (or on a Zoom call) is expense-minded or investment-minded right now. The biggest mistake web designers make is assuming they know, and pricing accordingly, before they've even had the conversation.
That's exactly what the Package Matrix™ is designed to solve.
What Is the Package Matrix™?
The Package Matrix™ is a three-option pricing framework that presents one offer at three different delivery levels, differentiated by access, customization, and level of service, not by deliverables. I created it after meeting value-based pricing expert Paul Klein and interviewing him on my podcast, and it’s evolved into the framework and system we use today to help web designers stop undercharging, raise their prices, and stop overdelivering and overworking.
It's one of the most important assets you will ever create in your business, and it’s a strategy backed by behavioral economics and pricing psychology. Let me walk you through why it works.
The 4 Rules of the Package Matrix™
Rule 1: Always Include Three Options Based on Pricing Paradigms™
Three options, one for each pricing paradigm: investment mindset, hustle mindset, and expense mindset. This is crucial because our brains need a frame of reference to make decisions. When you give someone a single option, they compare it to doing nothing (status quo bias), which almost always loses. When you give them three options, you've “designed the decision” as behavioral economist Melina Palmer would say.
Research backs this up. Three options framed properly convert at about 70% on average. One option converts at 20-30%. That's not a small difference.
And here's the thing: you don't need to figure out which paradigm your client is operating from. You just put all three options in front of them and let them choose. Zero pressure. You're not guessing what they can afford. You're giving them options and letting them tell you.
Rule 2: Options Are Apples to Apples
This is the piece that trips most people up. The Package Matrix™ is not three different packages. It's not a 20-page website, a 10-page website, and a one-pager. It's not e-commerce vs. no e-commerce vs. template site. It’s not tiered pricing.
Options are apples to apples. The destination is the same. The difference is the level of service.
Think of flying. First class, business class, economy: same destination, completely different experience. That's the Package Matrix™. Every client who works with you is going to get a website that achieves their goals. What varies is the level of strategy, customization, access to you, turnaround time, white-glove onboarding, training, support, the delivery experience.
Why does this matter so much? Because when a client chooses the expense-minded option, they are explicitly not choosing the higher-touch level of service. They saw it. They knew it was available. They explicitly did not choose it.
Rule 3: Use Value-Based Pricing, Not Cost-Based Pricing
This is the mindset shift that makes everything else work. Your price is not based on your hours, your skills, or your overhead. Your price is based on the value of the outcome your client can create as a result of working with you.
Value = (financial + emotional + time outcomes in their business and life) minus your price. That's it. Not your hours times your rate. Not your portfolio or how long you've been in business.
So you have to ask the questions. What is it worth to them to have a website that converts? How much time are they currently losing by doing it themselves? How would their life change if their site was actually generating leads consistently? What would make them really proud to share it? The answers to these questions are the anchors for your pricing.
This is why we never say “charge what you're worth” inside the Web Designer Academy. Your price isn't about your worth. Your price is about value to the client.
Rule 4: Anchor High
The first number a person hears becomes the price anchor. Everything after that gets compared to it. This is behavioral economics, and it is how our brains are wired.
When you ask a client what their budget is at the start of a consultation, you just set a low anchor and primed an expense-minded decision. When you list “starting at” prices on your website, you've done the same thing before the conversation even starts.
With the Package Matrix™, you always present the investment-minded option first. You say the high number first. Then you go down. Prices are decreasing, not rising. That completely changes how clients experience the decision. Instead of mimicking the feeling of prices going up (hello gas prices), it creates safety. The mid-level option starts to look like the wise choice. And you will be shocked by how often clients choose your highest option, especially at first.
When that happens consistently? It's a sign your high-end option is still priced too low. And that's a beautiful problem to have.
Real Results: What Happens When You Use the Package Matrix™
One of our Web Designer Academy students, Aprile, Package Matrixed™ her offers and sold a $15,000 project that she'd been charging $5,000 for. Same project. Same client type. Different pricing strategy.
We see this happen all the time. And here's the thing: when your high-end option keeps selling? That tells you you're still pricing it too low. Move it up. Create room for an even higher option. The floor of your pricing keeps rising.
The Package Matrix™ also does something that's just as valuable as making more money: it makes delivery more sustainable. When clients choose a package, they're choosing a level of service. That means your over-delivery problem starts to solve itself. You stop feeling responsible for outcomes that aren't yours to carry.
What I've shared with you today is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the Package Matrix™ strategy and how to properly create it and use it to stop undercharging, overdelivering and create freedom and flexibility in your web design business. We teach the full, end-to-end strategy inside the Web Designer Academy. Learn more here.
Who created the Package Matrix™?
Shannon Mattern, founder and CEO of the Web Designer Academy, created the Package Matrix™ framework in 2018 to empower web designers to safely test premium pricing. She now teaches it to all kinds of professional and creative services businesses and consultants via shannonmattern.com
What is a Package Matrix™?
The Package Matrix™ is a pricing and proposal framework designed for service-based businesses that sell customized, high-value work that naturally shifts the decision-point of the proposal from cost-based deliverables to value-based outcomes.
Who should use a Package Matrix™?
Creative service providers (brand designers, web designers, copywriters, UX/UI designers); Marketing and growth consultants (marketing strategists, fractional CMOs, SEO consultants, funnel strategists); Agencies and small teams (creative agencies, marketing agencies, web studios, content agencies); Business and professional consultants (business consultants, operations consultants, executive coaches, HR consultants); Tech and implementation specialists (developers, automation experts, CRM consultants, data analysts); Client experience and operations providers (OBMs, project managers, systems and workflow consultants); Specialized and niche consultants (PR consultants, accessibility consultants, community strategists, sustainability or DEI consultants). If a business is creating custom proposals, tailoring solutions for each client, and navigating pricing conversations, it’s a strong fit for a Package Matrix.™
Resources Mentioned in This Episode
- Package Matrix™ Template: webdesigneracademy.com/template
- Web Designer Academy: webdesigneracademy.com
- Next Level Mastermind: webdesigneracademy.com/next-level-mastermind
Related Episodes:
- Episode #180: The Truth About Pricing with Melina Palmer of The Brainy Business Podcast
- Episode #176: Web Design Business Pricing Insights From Inside the Web Designer Academy
- Episode #155: Web Design Sales Process: How To Make It More Chill and Client-Friendly
About Shannon Mattern
Shannon Mattern is a pricing strategist for service providers and the founder of the Web Designer Academy, where she helps experienced women web designers book higher-paying web design projects, charge more with confidence, run projects without overworking and burnout, and break through to their next level of income and freedom.
Website: webdesigneracademy.com
Instagram: @profitablewebdesigner
TikTok: @profitablewebdesigner
YouTube: @profitablewebdesigner
LinkedIn: shannonmattern